ecosystem · 6-8 · The meadow

One comes back. The other never does.

Two accounts of the same meadow. Energy flows through and leaves as heat. Carbon goes around and stays. Both panels, always.

species pair: flow vs. cyclescale: community ecosystemdouble witness
PredictTestExplainReviseDefendTransfer0/6 evidence steps
3-5
6-8
9-10
11-12
declared simplification: 6-8 pyramid renders detritus and decomposers as a single bar
producers250
herbivores120
carnivores40
detritus + decomposers90
heat — gone0
captured from the sun 127
still in living things 500
lost as heat 0
500 + 0 = 500 — balanced

Follow it far enough and it stops. There is no arrow out of heat.

The plants are respiring too. They always were — the pyramid just made it easy not to notice.

air (CO2)500
producers250
herbivores120
carnivores40
dead matter + soil70
decomposers20
total carbon 1000
unchanged since you started — nothing left, nothing arrived

Follow it far enough and you are back where you started. Nothing left and nothing arrived.

taken out — drag back to returnempty

Predict first: which panel changes shape, and which one only rearranges?

producers
250
herbivores
120
carnivores
40
decomposers
20
herbivore
9.0%
herbivores
carnivore
8.7%
carnivores
decomposer
8.8%
decomposers

It came out at four percent here. Ten was never a law; it was an average someone rounded.

Molecule
Cell
Organism
Population
Ecosystem
Molecule
Cell
Organism
Population
Ecosystem

Type your claim about this ecosystem. Choose the explanation type and scale level.

No moves yet — predict before you run.

Photosynthesis and respiration appear here as role — the mass ledger and pool accounting. Mechanism (the light reactions, electron transport) belongs to Cell World. Both worlds state the split.